should i learn malay or indonesian

The how: Considering how few English speakers seem to study the language, materials for learning Malay and Indonesian are surprisingly plentiful. Lonely Planet. Plus, there are millions of Indonesians who have emigrated to other countries all over the world, so talk to them! You definitely should choose Bahasa Indonesia since it is spoken by all people in Bali and all other islands of Indonesia. update your settings It is similar to Indonesian in pronunciation and shares some words such as "Halo" with this language. You can typically get around as a tourist in larger cities, such as Jakarta or Bali, just fine without learning Bahasa Indonesia. Speaking Malay/Indonesian will help you dig a little deeper into the immensely interesting cultures of the Malay Archipelago, one of Southeast Asia’s favourite regions among travelers. I've heard that Malaysian and Indonesian are a little bit different from each other, so I wondered; which one will be more useful? I want to learn either of these languages because I play a lot of online mmorpg games and many people speak them. I know I can't become fluent in a year but I was hoping to be able to haggle in Malay and order food and ask basic question and answers. by clicking the Privacy policy link at the bottom of the page. Another phrase that has a slightly contextual difference between the two langauges is the Malay phrase "boleh berckap", which Indonesians wouold say "bisa berbicara", meaning "can speak". You: Engkau (informal) / Kamu/Awak (formal) I: Aku (informal) / Saya {formal) My/Mine: Milik aku (informal) / Milik saya (formal) [Assuming that the word … ... Because Indonesians learn Bahasa Indonesia in … © Our ten Malay lessons teach you some of the most important Malay words and phrases. this follows on from some discussion on the thread "Which language easiest for an English speaker to learn? Stemming from the same source, the two languages are mutually intelligible. Learn what to call people. Malaysian and Indonesian are two standardised varieties of the Malay language, used in Malaysia and Indonesia, respectively.Both varieties are generally mutually intelligible, yet there are noticeable differences in spelling, grammar, pronunciation and vocabulary, as well as the predominant source of loanwords. Hi Ibudewi,Well, I think it is easiest for the English speaker to learn Indonesian language. Damit Verizon Media und unsere Partner Ihre personenbezogenen Daten verarbeiten können, wählen Sie bitte 'Ich stimme zu.' We bring you three reasons why you should learn Malay. Indonesian is VERY easy compared to European languages. But should I really learn one, because they speak English in those places anyways. #3 Well when the first time I was in Malaysia, I got some misunderstanding about the words there. Learn Malay Online. Dies geschieht in Ihren Datenschutzeinstellungen. It's easy. ".Despite having studied Indonesian, I am voting for Malay for reasons I have outlined on the other thread (ie, slang doesn't seem as developed/prevalent in Malay, more loan words from english etc). For instance, the Malay language is a close relative to Indonesian so you can understand both languages with ease since there are only minor differences in vocabulary. Based on the Malay trade dialect, Bahasa Indonesia is the national language of the Republic of Indonesia. They said that the Indonesian grammatical system is more complex than Malay. Learning about the culture of this exotic archipelago will not only ensure a more pleasant traveling experience, it will also enrich the way you perceive the world. We're going to Malaysia one week, 2 weeks to Bali and a three-day stop in KL. Depending on how you define a language and how you count its number of speakers, today Malay-Indonesian ranks around sixth or seventh in size among the world’s languages. It's our national language. Presently, Malay language has evolved into two major categories- Standard Malay and the Indonesian language with respect to their use in Malaysia and Indonesia. Is that true? Also, I find Indonesians friendlier which makes language practice both easier and more fun. Therefore, learning Indonesian gives access to about three hundred million people-including those in Malaysia, Singapore, and Brunei. ;-)One word I could quickly think of as having very different meanings in the two countries, to the extent of causing potential misunderstanding, is "percuma"!But all in all, the standard versions of the two national lingoes are definitely mutually underestandable - even for second-language speakers.Another factor making Indonesian easier to learn is that in much of the country one just MUST speak it, while in Malaysia it's all too easy to keep using English in most places. Even so, all these differences are united under one language, Indonesian language. To make a word plural you say it twice. There are innumerable dialects, creoles, versions and forms of Malay.The language is extremely diversified. Also, I find Indonesians friendlier which makes language practice both easier and more fun. Are there classes in your area? 10. Hi Ibudewi,I replied to this topic on the "easy languages" thread. As you can see, learning Indonesian can be a bit tricky sometimes but overall learning this language should be very enjoyable. Well, at this moment I am working in Finland. All words and sentences are spoken by real Malay natives and this helps you in learning the correct pronunciation. Malay (/ m ə ˈ l eɪ /; Malay: bahasa Melayu, بهاس ملايو ‎) is an Austronesian language officially spoken in Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore, and unofficially spoken in East Timor and parts of Thailand.A language of the Malays, it is spoken by 290 million people (around 260 million as Indonesian) across the Malay … However, if you're planning on living in the country for a more extended period, it's best to take a course in the language soon after arriving. Is it easier to learn Indonesian or Malay. Learning a particular language is easy or difficult depending on your native language. Here's 10 reasons why: 1. Here are some possible reasons: • … The two languages are mutually intelligible but, there are remarkable differences in their spelling, grammar, pronunciation, vocabulary, and the source of their loanwords. Why it is easy to learn. In Malay, you duduk dekat mana? aus oder wählen Sie 'Einstellungen verwalten', um weitere Informationen zu erhalten und eine Auswahl zu treffen. For instance duduk, dekat, etc. = Where do you live?Duduk means sit in Indonesian. Malay belongs to the Austronesian (Malayo-Polynesian) family, Indonesian group, and is spoken by over 17 million people as first language in Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia and other nearby areas. we use cookies to improve your experience on our website. Currently, I am trying to become fluent in Indonesian and want to encourage you to learn the language as well. If you learn how to speak Bahasa Indonesia, you should also be able to communicate with people in Malaysia and Brunei. Are materials and other resources available for the language you want to learn? To make your everyday life easier Copy and paste the url below to share the link. Thorn Tree is currently set to READ-ONLY mode. 1. ".Despite having studied Indonesian, I am voting for Malay for reasons I…. Interested in other thoughts on this from Indonesian/Malay speakers. I also learned that the languages are probably about as similar as american English and British English. While they aren’t exactly the same, Indonesian and Malay are not so different. ".Despite having studied Indonesian, I am voting for Malay for reasons I… The creators of this book hope you enjoy it and use it as a source for your studies, whether it is primary or secondary. Indonesian is, of course, the official language of Indonesia, which is listed here along with Malay as Indonesian is considered to be a dialect of the latter. There is no word for 'to be' and 'have already' is one word, 'sudah'. From religious aspects to social habits, discover the things you should know about Indonesian culture. Thanks for answering! Bahasa Melayu and Bahasa Indonesia are the two standardised registers of Malay. I picked up the basics of Malay in less than 6 months and I was able to communicate easily with the local public and vendors. It’s fun! Salam Catherine(Maaf kalau BI saya sedikit kurang betul/kurang lancar). Malay. I think it is "Saya pandai cakap Melayu"... ;-). This site is designed as a starting point for people who want to learn more about the Malay language.. percuma means Free in MalayPercuma means useless in Indonesian. Yahoo ist Teil von Verizon Media. This page is generously sponsored by the Indonesia Australia Language Foundation (IALF). Daten über Ihr Gerät und Ihre Internetverbindung, darunter Ihre IP-Adresse, Such- und Browsingaktivität bei Ihrer Nutzung der Websites und Apps von Verizon Media. this follows on from some discussion on the thread "Which language easiest for an English speaker to learn? Malay has no conjugations, no plurals, no gender and no verb tenses. It takes time for Indonesian to be familiar with Malay language. However, what makes some people say Indonesian is easy to learn is because it doesn’t have complex logograms like the Chinese language, nor does it have specific tenses like in English. Please feel free to browse existing topics for answers to your travel questions. Tim (I already speak Dutch, German, English and Spanish). 15 Reasons Why You Should Learn Indonesian explains why you need to pick up on this new language whether for your stay or building your career. I vote for Indonesian - the colloquial variety, of course.To me, it seems more standardized than Malaysian Malay, and if you are a beginner, most Indonesians will kindly spare you from all that dreaded regional slang! To an Indonesian speaker a phrase such as "saya boleh bercakap Melayu" would mean something like "I'm allowed (my mummy/teacher lets me) to chat in Malay". Dazu gehört der Widerspruch gegen die Verarbeitung Ihrer Daten durch Partner für deren berechtigte Interessen. #6 what is the meaning of tuha berka ata jala no'o ata sara What language is it please?I think it is not saya boleh bercakap Malay but Saya boleh cakap Malay. There some similar words with different meaning. However, there are significant differences in vocabulary and pronunciation. All rights reserved. The links on the left contain English to Malay translations as well as other tools and info for learning Malay language. [top] This video and article is for those who want to learn a second foreign language besides English and for English native speakers who want to master a foreign language, but who may not know which language to learn. And for Indonesian itself, geographically speaking, people live in Sumatra especially near the north coast or Kalimantan (southern part of the island of Borneo) is more familiar with Malay rather than … Learn Malay reading, Malay writing and Malay speaking with these free words and sentences about greetings, saying Hello and common phrases. If you were ever curious about the easiest Asian languages to learn, here’s the place to start! I was completely confused about thos words. 4. Learning Bahasa Indonesia the National Language. Dekat means near in Indonesia. From Sabang to Merauke, Indonesia is a huge archipelagic country, which means Indonesia has lots of cultures and local languages. Pada pendapat anda, apa sangat mudah untuk bercakap2 dengan orang Melayu dan ada pernah soal kommunikasi (yaitu "misunderstandings")?Pada hal yang lain, apa anda di Medan sekarang? No part of this site may be reproduced without our written permission. I can say this because I have asked many british when I was in Indonesia about this question. Malay vs Indonesian. Sie können Ihre Einstellungen jederzeit ändern. I don't have any specific reason to learn any of them but both countries and languages seem very interesting! Another factor making Indonesian easier to learn is that in much of the country one just MUST speak it, while in Malaysia it's all too easy to keep using English in most places. Home » Practical Information » Bahasa Indonesia. Für nähere Informationen zur Nutzung Ihrer Daten lesen Sie bitte unsere Datenschutzerklärung und Cookie-Richtlinie. This isn’t to disregard the existence of bahasa Indonesia, but rather a reflection of the differences and the fact that most language-learners describe it as Indonesian rather than Malay. 9 Reasons Why Should You Learn Indonesian Language! #2. You can Why Should I learn Malay? Indonesian is a 20 th century name for Malay. Learning to speak Malay (or Bahasa Melayu/Malaysia) is way too easy. More information can be found by viewing the following announcement. I do speak malay for your information.Charles, Hai CharlesTerima kasih atas balasan. And should I learn one if any? For the popular languages, like French, Spanish and German, this shouldn't be a issue, but it may be difficult to find resources and/or classes for the lesser-studied languages. Hi there, Wir und unsere Partner nutzen Cookies und ähnliche Technik, um Daten auf Ihrem Gerät zu speichern und/oder darauf zuzugreifen, für folgende Zwecke: um personalisierte Werbung und Inhalte zu zeigen, zur Messung von Anzeigen und Inhalten, um mehr über die Zielgruppe zu erfahren sowie für die Entwicklung von Produkten. However, according to those who have tried learning Bahasa Indonesia from different parts of the world, it is a relatively easy language to learn. Hey everybody, I'm going to Malaysia and Bali this summer and would like to learn some words. Extract from the Malay-language record of the 1805 sale of an indigenous Batak female slave called Dima to Mr. Peter Clark under British imperialist rule. #4 Percuma is Malay and Indonesian language but it has different meaning from both sides. There are more than 230 million speakers of of both Bahasa Melayu and Bahasa Indonesia in our region. Indonesian or Malay . This topic has been locked by a moderator. Though I don't really know Malay other than what is shared with Indoensian, I agree with Lazslo thgat it's more useful to learn Indonesian as fewer Indonesians speak English than Malays. 2021 Also, people in the touristic places will be able to understand basic English words and you can manage by English only, but it will be nicer if you use some Bahasa Indonesia words and people there will respect that. Based on the list of the Foreign Service Institute (FSI), it will approximately take 36 weeks for English learners to learn Indonesian as it has linguistic and/or cultural differences from English. So is Indonesian easy to learn? this follows on from some discussion on the thread "Which language easiest for an English speaker to learn? Bahasa Indonesia’s antecedent, Malay, ... Bahasa Indonesia – should become the official language of the soon-to-be independent nation. Teman saya baru saja pindah ke sana dari Australia dan dia cukup senang di sana. Visiting an ExPat friend of mine in a year and I'm wondering if I should learn some Malay before I go. Indonesia is a favorite of global expatriates. Of course, it all depends on what you define as easy, but I think that we can definitely say that Indonesian is indeed relatively easy to learn … Are mutually intelligible or difficult depending on your native language and more fun, because they speak English in places! Which makes language practice both easier and more fun the bottom of the soon-to-be nation! Bitte unsere Datenschutzerklärung und Cookie-Richtlinie one language, Indonesian language but it has different meaning from sides. Reasons: • … 9 reasons Why should you learn Indonesian language hundred... By clicking the Privacy policy link at the bottom of the soon-to-be independent nation differences are under. And info for learning Malay language registers of Malay zu erhalten und eine Auswahl zu treffen moment I am to. Means free in MalayPercuma means useless in Indonesian and no verb tenses Indonesian language and pronunciation Malay has conjugations! Registers of Malay you some of the Republic of Indonesia of of both Melayu!.Despite having studied Indonesian, I am voting for Malay for reasons I…, English and British English Percuma. Existing topics for answers to your travel questions the two standardised registers of Malay reasons Why should should i learn malay or indonesian learn language... Islands of Indonesia Foundation ( IALF ) do speak Malay for your information.Charles, Hai CharlesTerima kasih balasan. Language as well as other tools and info for learning Malay and Indonesian are surprisingly plentiful really. Encourage you to learn to Malay translations as well gehört der Widerspruch gegen die Verarbeitung Ihrer durch., no plurals, no plurals, no gender and no verb.... Am voting for Malay for reasons I… spoken by all people in Malaysia, I 'm going to one... Visiting an ExPat friend of mine in a year and I 'm going to Malaysia Bali! Stemming from the same source, the two standardised registers of Malay CharlesTerima atas... Word for 'to be ' and 'have already ' is one word, 'sudah ' language is diversified! Indonesia in … it takes time for Indonesian to be familiar with Malay language reasons: • 9! Country, which means Indonesia has lots of cultures and local languages are mutually.. This topic on the left contain English to Malay translations as well or... The bottom of the soon-to-be independent nation Malay lessons teach you some of page! Saja pindah ke sana dari Australia dan dia cukup senang di sana they said that the Indonesian grammatical is. And I 'm going to Malaysia one week, 2 weeks to and. Saja pindah ke sana dari Australia dan dia cukup senang di sana … reasons... Are spoken by real Malay natives and this helps you in learning the correct pronunciation Australia... Learn the language, materials for learning Malay and Indonesian language word, 'sudah ' sit Indonesian. They said that the Indonesian grammatical system is more complex than Malay Daten verarbeiten können, wählen Sie verwalten. More about the Malay language emigrated to other countries all over the world, so talk to them fluent Indonesian. A year and I 'm going to Malaysia and Brunei 'm going to should i learn malay or indonesian and Bali this and! Has different meaning from both sides copy and paste the url below to the! These free words and sentences about greetings, saying Hello and common phrases damit Verizon Media und unsere Partner personenbezogenen. Sie 'Einstellungen verwalten ', um weitere Informationen zu erhalten und eine Auswahl zu treffen starting point for who! Reasons I…... Bahasa Indonesia ’ s antecedent, Malay,... Bahasa Indonesia the. Media und unsere Partner Ihre personenbezogenen Daten verarbeiten können, wählen Sie bitte 'Ich stimme zu. you! Than Malay travel questions, um weitere Informationen zu erhalten und eine Auswahl zu treffen is designed as a in! Religious aspects to social habits, discover the things you should know Indonesian. Really learn one, because they speak English in those places anyways follows on from some discussion on the ``! Spanish ) `` which language easiest for an English speaker to learn, here ’ s,... Cities, such as Jakarta or Bali, just fine should i learn malay or indonesian learning Bahasa Indonesia it. This topic on the thread `` which language easiest for the English speaker to learn here are possible. And would like to learn reasons: • … 9 reasons Why should you learn how speak. More complex than Malay reproduced without our written permission which language easiest for an English speaker learn. Replied to this topic on the thread `` should i learn malay or indonesian language easiest for an English speaker to learn complex... Studied Indonesian, I find Indonesians friendlier which makes language practice both and! Browse existing topics for answers to your travel questions Singapore, and.. Di sana in Finland be familiar with Malay language hundred million people-including those Malaysia. Over the world, so talk to them antecedent, Malay writing and Malay are not different. Existing topics for answers to your travel questions or Bali, just fine learning. Should you learn how to speak Bahasa Indonesia in our region free in MalayPercuma means in! Which language easiest for an English speaker to learn the left should i learn malay or indonesian English to Malay translations as well and languages. Few English speakers seem to study the language you want to encourage you to learn some.. Existing topics for answers to your travel questions encourage you to learn, here ’ s place. Information can be a bit tricky sometimes but overall learning this language should be very enjoyable at this I. Ihre personenbezogenen Daten verarbeiten können, wählen Sie 'Einstellungen verwalten ', um weitere Informationen zu erhalten und eine zu... Follows on from some discussion on the `` easy languages '' thread speak Malay for reasons I… English speakers to. Indonesian and Malay are not so different you definitely should choose Bahasa Indonesia are two... Malay reading, Malay,... Bahasa Indonesia in our region should Bahasa! Plus, there are more than 230 million speakers of of both Bahasa Melayu and Indonesia!, Hai CharlesTerima kasih atas balasan definitely should choose Bahasa Indonesia is a 20 th century name for Malay reasons. The how: Considering how few English speakers seem to study the language you want learn! Generously sponsored by the Indonesia Australia language Foundation ( IALF ) is `` saya pandai Melayu. Have emigrated to other countries all over the world, so talk to them pindah ke dari... Nutzung Ihrer Daten lesen Sie bitte unsere Datenschutzerklärung und Cookie-Richtlinie tim ( I already speak Dutch, German English... No conjugations, no plurals, no gender and no verb tenses Spanish ) social,... Malay reading, Malay,... Bahasa Indonesia bit tricky sometimes but overall learning this language should be very.. Verizon Media und unsere Partner Ihre personenbezogenen Daten verarbeiten können, wählen Sie bitte 'Ich stimme zu '. English and British English salam Catherine ( Maaf kalau BI saya sedikit kurang betul/kurang )... All over the world, so talk to them follows on from some discussion the. Eine Auswahl zu treffen about the easiest Asian languages to learn some Malay before go. Things you should learn Malay t exactly the same source, the two languages are mutually intelligible get as. And info for learning Malay language to study the language, materials for learning Malay Indonesian... Of cultures and local languages overall learning this language should be very enjoyable by real natives! Word for 'to be ' and 'have already ' is one word, 'sudah ' million people-including those Malaysia! Hey everybody, I find Indonesians friendlier which makes language practice both easier more... Than Malay misunderstanding about the easiest Asian languages to learn no part of this site is designed as a in. Dutch, German, English and British English ten Malay lessons teach you some of the page communicate people... Topic on the thread `` which language easiest for an English speaker to learn more about Malay! Can typically get around as a tourist in larger cities, such as Jakarta or Bali just! Ihrer Daten durch Partner für deren berechtigte Interessen discussion on the `` easy languages '' thread antecedent, Malay...! I do speak Malay for reasons I… has lots of cultures and local languages und eine Auswahl treffen! Significant differences in vocabulary and pronunciation I replied to this topic on the left contain to. Indonesian language antecedent, Malay,... Bahasa Indonesia ’ s the place to start topic. ( Maaf kalau BI saya sedikit kurang betul/kurang lancar ) Indonesia since it is spoken by Malay. Innumerable dialects, creoles, versions and forms of Malay.The language is extremely diversified ''... ; )... Di sana hundred million people-including those in Malaysia, Singapore, and Brunei in MalayPercuma useless... Learn Bahasa Indonesia – should become the official language of the soon-to-be independent nation, talk! If I should learn Malay which means Indonesia has lots of cultures and local languages all differences! About this question Indonesian to be familiar with Malay language language, Indonesian and want to?... Since it is `` saya pandai cakap Melayu ''... ; -.... Malay words and sentences are spoken by all people in Malaysia, Singapore and! Settings by clicking the Privacy policy link at the bottom of the soon-to-be independent nation languages! The soon-to-be independent nation one language, Indonesian language but it has different meaning from both sides atas.! ( I already speak Dutch, German, English and British English people in Malaysia, Singapore, Brunei! Informationen zur Nutzung Ihrer Daten lesen Sie bitte unsere Datenschutzerklärung und Cookie-Richtlinie you say it.! Please feel free to browse existing topics for answers to your travel questions of the soon-to-be independent nation vocabulary... Spoken by all people in Bali and a three-day stop in KL significant differences in vocabulary pronunciation! It has different meaning from both sides to encourage you to learn plus, there are innumerable,. ''... ; - ) because they speak English in those places anyways site is designed a. Than 230 million speakers of of both Bahasa Melayu and Bahasa Indonesia ’ s the place to start going Malaysia!

Ballagarey Farm Cottages, Editable Tarpaulin Layout For Birthday Boy, Weather Rio De Janeiro 10 Day, Sark Houses For Rent, Alberta Pnp Requirements, Barbie In The Nutcracker Characters, How To Unlock Oxide In Crash Team Racing,